Conservatory Roof ReplacementDerby
A large glasshouse with tall arched windows and ivy-covered pillars behind a striped lawn and flower beds

Solid, Glass or Polycarbonate: Conservatory Roof Options in Derby

Most people start out sure they want a solid roof, then wonder about the light. Here is how the three choices really compare once they are on.

The three roofs side by side

General differences, not promises. The exact result depends on the product, how it is fitted and which way your conservatory faces.

What changesPolycarbonateGlassTiled warm roof
Light in the roomBright, slightly diffusedBrightest, clear view of the skyMuch darker unless you add roof windows or a lantern
Summer heatGets hotBetter with solar control coatings, still warmStays closest to the rest of the house
Winter warmthLoses heat quicklyBetter than old roofs, still cooler than a roomInsulated, so it holds heat far better
Rain noiseLoud drummingQuieterQuiet, like an ordinary room
Weight on the frameLightestHeavier than sheetsHeaviest; frame and base need checking
Building RegulationsUsually not needed for a straight swapUsually not needed for a straight swapUsually needed

A solid, tiled warm roof

This is the change that turns a conservatory into something closer to an extension. The old roof comes off and a new one is built with insulation, a breathable membrane and lightweight tiles outside, with a plastered ceiling inside. A warm roof simply means the insulation sits in the roof itself, so the room below stays at a steadier temperature.

Is your conservatory too hot to sit in by June and too cold to use from November? Then this is usually the roof that fixes both. What you give up is daylight, and you take on some paperwork. The sky view goes unless you add roof windows or a lantern, and the work normally needs Building Regulations approval, because once the roof is solid the building stops being an exempt conservatory.

Weight matters too. Building control will want to know the existing frames, the supports around the doors and the foundations can carry the new roof, so expect a proper survey. More on that on our Derby rules page.

Good if

You want a year-round room, the frame and base are sound, and you are happy with a ceiling over your head.

Think twice if

The sky view is the reason you love the room, or the frame is already tired and moving.

Double-glazed glass

Pick glass and you keep the reasons most people built a conservatory at all: daylight, the garden overhead and that half-outdoors feeling. What has moved on is the glass. Modern sealed units can carry coatings that reflect some of the sun's heat and cut glare, and self-cleaning finishes are common.

You may find a glass roof is the answer if the old one leaks or has gone cloudy but you mostly use the room from spring to autumn. It will not behave like an insulated room in winter, and on a south-facing conservatory it can still get warm, but it is a real step up from tired sheets.

Glass weighs more than polycarbonate, so a fitter should still check the frame, though the jump is far smaller than with a tiled roof.

Good if

Light comes first, the frame is in good order and you want a cleaner, quieter roof without building work.

Think twice if

You want to use the room as a study or living space in deep winter.

New polycarbonate sheets

Polycarbonate is the lightweight plastic sheeting many older conservatories were built with. Replacing tired or discoloured sheets with new ones in the existing frame is the smallest job of the three and the one that costs least.

It is honest to say what it will not do. Polycarbonate lets heat in and out easily, and heavy rain on it is loud. In a lot of cases people choose it because the room is used for plants, storage or summer evenings, and a clean, sound roof is all they need.

Thicker, multi-wall sheets perform better than the thin sheets of older roofs, so ask what is being quoted. The Derby cost page shows how far apart the three roofs are on price.

Good if

The budget is tight, the room is seasonal, and the frame is fine but the sheets are tired.

Think twice if

Noise in the rain or cold in winter is what bothers you most.

Matching the roof to a Derby house

Derby has a lot of older housing. The council lists 16 conservation areas, including Victorian suburbs such as Strutts Park, the Arboretum and Little Chester, and old village centres like Darley Abbey and Spondon. If your conservatory sits behind one of those houses, the look of the new roof matters as well as how it performs.

A glass or polycarbonate swap keeps the shape and look of the conservatory much as it was, which is why it rarely raises questions. A tiled roof changes the silhouette, the colour and the pitch the neighbours see. Usually that is no problem, though for a listed house, or one in a conservation area, Derby City Council should hear about it before you sign.

On a newer estate the choice usually comes down to the room itself. Which way does it face? How do you want to use it? Is the frame sound? Those three questions settle it more often than anything else.

Not sure which roof yet? Get a quote anyway

Once someone has stood in the room and looked at the frame, the choice usually gets much easier.

No charge to you. We line up a roof firm that works around your postcode, tell you who they are, and hold on to your details until you agree. How it is arranged

Your details
Get a quote